Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

November 30, 2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the
Momentum
BY DAVID EDELMAN ON NOVEMBER 1, 2020

Editor’s note: In light of the student strike, The Clerk has elected to halt our normal news
coverage. However, we will continue our coverage of the strike and related events to highlight the
activism of BIPOC students, their demands, and the overall need for institutional change. Staff
members will be donating compensation for these articles to local mutual aid organizations.
In the wake of the Founders Hall march on October 28, the majority of Haverford’s student
body went on strike to protest the killing of Walter Wallace Jr. by police in Philadelphia and
the response to Wallace’s death by Haverford’s administration.
haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

1/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

Strike organizers sent out an email to all students on the afternoon of October 29, linking to
a document entitled “HC STRIKE 2020 STATEMENT & DEMANDS”. Students were asked to
commit to the strike by halting their involvement with any college-related activities,
including attending classes, working on-campus jobs, and participating in extracurriculars
or athletics.
The email was signed by Women of Color House, Black Students Refusing Further Inaction—
the authors of the June open letter to the presidents of both Bi-Co schools—the Black
Student League, and “every single BIPOC student this institution has failed”.
In their statement, the strike organizers criticized the email sent by President Raymond and
Dean Bylander on October 28 that asked students not to attend the protests over Wallace’s
death in Philadelphia, calling the administration’s message “a continuation of a long
tradition of anti-Blackness and the erasure of marginalized voices that have come to
characterize the experiences of students of color at Haverford.”
Given Haverford’s public support for anti-racism and social justice work, the organizers
found it hypocritical that the administration opted not to support student protesters,
especially since the college often touts its proximity to Philadelphia. “You are not only
silencing our voices and preventing us from protesting the violence enacted on Black
people,” they wrote, “but actively stopping us from reinforcing the dignity and humanity of
Black lives by showing up for community members down the street.”
The organizers rejected President Raymond and Dean Bylander’s calls for students to
instead make their voices heard on Election Day, arguing that only abolition, not electoral
politics, can bring about racial equality. They pointed out that Wallace was killed by police
in Philadelphia, which has long been controlled by Democrats.
“This campus can’t run without BIPOC,” wrote the organizers, framing the strike as an
opportunity for BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and people of color) students to demand
institutional change by making the school grind to a halt.
Below the statement, the organizers listed twelve demands for President Raymond and Dean
Bylander. First up: the resignation of Wendy Raymond as Chief Diversity Of cer—a role she
holds concurrently with that of President of the College—and her replacement with a BIPOC
Chief Diversity Of cer.
Two days after the Founders Hall protest, President Wendy Raymond issued her rst
response to the strike, agreeing to some of the organizers’ demands and pledging that she
would send a more-depth statement next week.
haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

2/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

President Raymond noted that her term as Chief Diversity Of cer would be expiring on July
1, 2021, and promised to announce the appointment of a replacement on or before that date.
It’s not clear whether this will entail an entirely new position or the expansion of an existing
administrator’s portfolio; in President Raymond’s July response to the BSRFI letter, she had
said that either option was possible.
With the endorsement of the faculty and the Staff Association Executive Committee,
President Raymond approved the second item: an Election Day holiday for students and
staff (a change that had already been implemented by Swarthmore’s president). She noted
that some hourly, non-exempt staff would continue to work on Tuesday but would receive
holiday pay.
Organizers also demanded that Haverford continue to pay students who are on strike and
that the college not retaliate against any strike participants. President Raymond agreed to
this issue as well, announcing that students on strike would be compensated for up to 20
hours of pre-scheduled work.
Returning to one of the issues that had ignited the Founders Hall protest, the administration
agreed to support student protesters by providing no-questions-asked COVID testing for
students who may have been exposed while in public. “For those opting to strike or protest,
we trust that you will do so while remaining socially distanced and masked as best you can,”
wrote President Raymond.
Yet many of the items within the organizers’ statement went unanswered in President
Raymond’s response. These included calls for the college to end any relationship with the
Philadelphia Police Department, endorse police and prison abolition, and divest from prison
labor.
In the realm of academics, the organizers had proposed better support for faculty of color
and the creation of a new framework for holding problematic professors accountable. A past
attempt by the student body to expand the reach of the Academic Honor Code during the
Honor Code Crisis of 2018 was met with resistance from the faculty and administrators over
concerns surrounding academic freedom and legal liability.
President Raymond also did not respond to the demand for academic leniency for BIPOC
and rst-generation/low-income (FGLI) students who have suffered from the effects of the
pandemic and police violence. Thus far, that process has generally been left up to the
discretion of individual faculty, which the statement says has allowed many professors to
“ atly ignore” the needs of students of color.

haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

3/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

Two other demands that President Raymond has not yet addressed were items X and XI,
which called for more support for disabled students as well as queer and trans students of
color. Among the proposed changes under these headings are the hiring of more LGBTQ+
and BIPOC staff at Counseling and Psychological Services. However, some students
questioned the push to end mandatory reporting—a duty imposed by federal and state law—
and to require the permission of students before involving campus safety in mental health
crises.
“If a student is having a mental health crisis or feels suicidal, they would probably not
consent to calling Campus Safety or having anybody else involved for various reasons,” said
one student, who asked to remain anonymous. “However, only having friends and family
know about these issues is also dangerous for the student and puts an unhealthy amount of
stress and responsibility on those friends and family—especially since sometimes these
situations require physical restraint to stop someone from harming themself.”
The student suggested that a more effective solution might involve the creation of a mental
health crisis team on campus.
Finally, while President Raymond acknowledged the work of “the organizers (students in
Women of Color House) and many others (including students from Black Students Refusing
Further Inaction, the Black Student League, and entire networks of BIPOC students)” in her
email, she did not speci cally address the demand to “honor and credit the work of Black
women driving institutional change.” During the Founders Hall protest, several speakers
noted that Haverford had previously failed to credit the work of BSRFI in crafting anti-racist
policies at the college in their public materials, including in the alumni magazine. How
Haverford would ensure Black women receive their due credit, however, is somewhat
unclear, as the demand does not specify concrete actions.
President Raymond stated her intention to write a more comprehensive response next week,
within the two-week window laid out by the organizers to address these demands.
As of Saturday, October 31, it seems that most of the Haverford community has heeded the
call for a student strike. Many professors cancelled class on Thursday and Friday, and those
who did not were often greeted with sparse attendance. Thus far, over 700 students and two
dozen faculty have signed a pledge to uphold the strike until President Wendy Raymond and
Interim Dean of the College Joyce Bylander agree to the organizers’ demands.
Although there was some early confusion around whether continuing to do coursework
counts as crossing the picket line, a consensus seems to have developed that it does. A post
from the organizers’ Instagram account captured the mood, stating that “STRIKING in
haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

4/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

Solidarity with the BIPOC community at Haverford is NOT a time for rest NOR asynchronous
schoolwork.”
Nevertheless, conversations have revealed that some students, even those who signed in
support of the strike, are continuing to do coursework. One student who spoke on the
condition of anonymity deemed this “disingenuous and hypocritical.” Another was less
harsh, but commented, “Even if you’re doing your own assignments, that means you’re
getting ahead of your peers.”
Like the calls for the Founders Hall protest, information about the student strike spread
rapidly across the college, particularly via Instagram accounts like @hc_strike that gave
students the ability to repost to their stories guidelines on how to strike, links to the Bi-Co
Mutual Aid network, and alternatives to the Dining Center and the Coop.

Caption: Two examples of Instagram posts from the strike organizers

Bi-Co Mutual Aid, which launched in September, saw a massive surge in donations, raising
over $70,000 in the 48 hours after the protest. According to the group, the funds will be used
to pay students for wages lost during the strike, purchasing food supplies, and supporting
the protests in Philadelphia. Fundraising efforts were so successful that late on Friday night,
in light of the amount of money raised, Bi-Co Mutual Aid asked the community to redirect
their contributions to Philadelphia community organizations or to the Haverford Strike
fund.
The Students’ Council Treasurers, Lisette Pham ’23 and Rasaaq Shittu ’23, announced they
would also reimburse students who nancially support the strike—by purchasing communal
haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

5/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

groceries or protest supplies, for example—out of StuCo funds. According to the Treasurers’
email, legal restrictions prohibit StuCo from directly donating to the Mutual Aid fund.
Alongside promoting direct nancial support, strike organizers told students to avoid eating
at the Coop so as not to overburden Haverford staff while student workers strike. While
there was some initial confusion over whether this recommendation applied to the Dining
Center as well, an October 31 strike update clari ed that eating at the DC “is not an act that
crosses the picket line.” Dining Services General Manager Tom Mitchell con rmed in an
October 30 email that the DC would be able to feed students during the strike.
However, the organizers suggested that students living in the Apartments avoid the DC, if
possible, in favor of alternatives. Students with the nancial means to do so were
encouraged to buy their own food, while BIPOC and FGLI students have rst dibs on The
Nest, Haverford’s food pantry. Other food options open to all students include The Burrow
Café, Haverford’s student-run, pay-what-you-can café that emerged in the wake of the
strike; various groups on campus such as Ehaus and Quaker House have also been putting
meals together.

Supplies are available at The Nest, Haverford’s food pantry. (Image courtesy of The Nest.)

haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

6/13

11/30/2020

Three Days into the Student Strike, the Organizers Have the Momentum – The Clerk

In the update sent via email on Saturday afternoon, strike organizers announced that they
will be hosting a student Town Hall over Zoom on Sunday, November 1, which will address
ways in which both on-campus and remote students can support the strike. The message
also contained a link to a form that students can use to submit questions for the Town Hall.
A separate Town Hall with faculty is scheduled for Monday, November 2nd, also to be held
on Zoom.
Published in News
Bi-Co Mutual Aid

BSRFI

student strike

Wendy Raymond

More from News

More posts in News »

Upperclassmen Mourn Loss of Study
Abroad, But Sophomores Are Hopeful
for 2021

Breaking: The Strike Is Over After Two
Full Weeks

Con icting Visions of the Strike’s End
as Negotiations Deteriorate

At the Second Sit-In: Reminders of
Haverford’s Broken Promises,

haverfordclerk.com/three-days-into-the-student-strike-the-organizers-have-the-momentum/

7/13